# Where is the cheapest makeup in the New York, NY area?

Source: https://aislesinventory.com/new-york/answers/cheapest-makeup
Updated Oct 19, 2026 (2026-10-19T17:13:39.165Z)
Last checked by Aisles: between Oct 18, 2026, 2:29 AM EDT and Oct 19, 2026, 1:13 PM EDT (2026-10-18T06:29:31.596Z to 2026-10-19T17:13:39.165Z); the most recent check was 12 hours before this page was generated.
Page generated: Oct 20, 2026, 12:56 AM EDT (2026-10-20T04:56:44.348Z)

As of Aisles' last check (Oct 19, 2026, 1:13 PM EDT), the lowest-priced makeup reported in stock in the New York, NY area is Ardell Wispies, Demi, 1 Pair (Size One Size, Black) for $4.50 at JCPenney Roosevelt Field, 630 Old Country Rd, Garden City, NY 11530. Package sizes differ, so compare sizes as well as prices. Prices and availability are as reported by ATHLETA, Dick's Sporting Goods, Express, JCPenney, Macy's, and Nordstrom.

On this page:

- [Lowest in-stock price for each makeup product](https://aislesinventory.com/new-york/answers/cheapest-makeup#cheapest)
- [Cheapest by chain](https://aislesinventory.com/new-york/answers/cheapest-makeup#by-chain)
- [Related](https://aislesinventory.com/new-york/answers/cheapest-makeup#related)
- [Questions shoppers ask](https://aislesinventory.com/new-york/answers/cheapest-makeup#questions)

- Products compared: 1,881
- Lowest price: $4.50
- Stores checked: 6

> Availability is reported by each retailer and checked by Aisles about once a day. It can change at any time, and Aisles does not physically verify stock. Confirm with the store before making a special trip.

## Lowest in-stock price for each makeup product

| Product | Size | Lowest price | Where | Availability |
| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
| [Ardell Wispies, Demi, 1 Pair](https://aislesinventory.com/new-york/products/ardell-ardell-wispies-demi-1-pair-simon-jcpenney-ppr5008202654-2774) | Size One Size, Black | $4.50 | [JCPenney Roosevelt Field, Garden City](https://aislesinventory.com/new-york/garden-city/jcpenney-roosevelt-field-garden-city-roosevelt-field/ardell-ardell-wispies-demi-1-pair-simon-jcpenney-ppr5008202654-2774) | In stock |
| [Real Techniques Disposable Dual-Ended Spoolies](https://aislesinventory.com/new-york/products/real-techniques-disposable-dual-ended-spoolies-simon-jcpenney-ppr5008441862-2774) | Size One Size | $4.50 | [JCPenney Roosevelt Field, Garden City](https://aislesinventory.com/new-york/garden-city/jcpenney-roosevelt-field-garden-city-roosevelt-field/real-techniques-disposable-dual-ended-spoolies-simon-jcpenney-ppr5008441862-2774) | In stock |
| [Ardell 3D Faux Mink 859 Lashes](https://aislesinventory.com/new-york/products/ardell-ardell-3d-faux-mink-859-lashes-simon-jcpenney-ppr5008202661-2774) | Size One Size, Black | $4.75 | [JCPenney Roosevelt Field, Garden City](https://aislesinventory.com/new-york/garden-city/jcpenney-roosevelt-field-garden-city-roosevelt-field/ardell-ardell-3d-faux-mink-859-lashes-simon-jcpenney-ppr5008202661-2774) | In stock |
| [Distant Lands 8 oz. Champagne Blush Hand Soap](https://aislesinventory.com/new-york/products/distant-lands-distant-lands-8-oz-champagne-blush-hand-soap-simon-jcpenney-ppr5008661634-2774) | Size One Size, Champagne Blush | $4.99 | [JCPenney Roosevelt Field, Garden City](https://aislesinventory.com/new-york/garden-city/jcpenney-roosevelt-field-garden-city-roosevelt-field/distant-lands-distant-lands-8-oz-champagne-blush-hand-soap-simon-jcpenney-ppr5008661634-2774) | In stock |
| [Covergirl Easy Breezy Brow Fill + Define Brow Pencil](https://aislesinventory.com/new-york/products/covergirl-covergirl-easy-breezy-brow-fill-define-brow-pencil-simon-jcpenney-ppr5008159993-2774) | 2 sizes/colors | $5.99 | [JCPenney Roosevelt Field, Garden City](https://aislesinventory.com/new-york/garden-city/jcpenney-roosevelt-field-garden-city-roosevelt-field/covergirl-covergirl-easy-breezy-brow-fill-define-brow-pencil-simon-jcpenney-ppr5008159993-2774) | In stock |
| [Eyeshadow Girls Eyeshadow Big Kid Girls A-Line Skirt](https://aislesinventory.com/new-york/products/eyeshadow-girls-eyeshadow-big-kid-girls-a-line-skirt-simon-jcpenney-ppr5008522095-2774) | Size Large, Burgundy Multi | $5.99 | [JCPenney Roosevelt Field, Garden City](https://aislesinventory.com/new-york/garden-city/jcpenney-roosevelt-field-garden-city-roosevelt-field/eyeshadow-girls-eyeshadow-big-kid-girls-a-line-skirt-simon-jcpenney-ppr5008522095-2774) | In stock |
| [Nyx Professional Makeup Butter Gloss Non-Sticky Lip Gloss](https://aislesinventory.com/new-york/products/nyx-professional-makeup-nyx-professional-makeup-butter-gloss-non-simon-jcpenney-ppr5008436584-2774) | 21 sizes/colors | $6.00 | [JCPenney Roosevelt Field, Garden City](https://aislesinventory.com/new-york/garden-city/jcpenney-roosevelt-field-garden-city-roosevelt-field/nyx-professional-makeup-nyx-professional-makeup-butter-gloss-non-simon-jcpenney-ppr5008436584-2774) | In stock |
| [Nyx Professional Makeup Butter Gloss Non-Sticky Lip Gloss](https://aislesinventory.com/new-york/products/nyx-professional-makeup-nyx-professional-makeup-butter-gloss-non-simon-jcpenney-ppr5008458951-2774) | 4 sizes/colors | $6.00 | [JCPenney Roosevelt Field, Garden City](https://aislesinventory.com/new-york/garden-city/jcpenney-roosevelt-field-garden-city-roosevelt-field/nyx-professional-makeup-nyx-professional-makeup-butter-gloss-non-simon-jcpenney-ppr5008458951-2774) | In stock |
| [Nyx Professional Makeup Jumbo Eye Pencil](https://aislesinventory.com/new-york/products/nyx-professional-makeup-nyx-professional-makeup-jumbo-eye-pencil-simon-jcpenney-ppr5008436519-2774) | 8 sizes/colors | $6.00 | [JCPenney Roosevelt Field, Garden City](https://aislesinventory.com/new-york/garden-city/jcpenney-roosevelt-field-garden-city-roosevelt-field/nyx-professional-makeup-nyx-professional-makeup-jumbo-eye-pencil-simon-jcpenney-ppr5008436519-2774) | In stock |
| [Nyx Professional Makeup Party Animals Butter Gloss Bling Metallic (Limited Edition)](https://aislesinventory.com/new-york/products/nyx-professional-makeup-party-animals-butter-gloss-bling-metallic-simon-jcpenney-ppr5008753685-2774) | 2 sizes/colors | $6.00 | [JCPenney Roosevelt Field, Garden City](https://aislesinventory.com/new-york/garden-city/jcpenney-roosevelt-field-garden-city-roosevelt-field/nyx-professional-makeup-party-animals-butter-gloss-bling-metallic-simon-jcpenney-ppr5008753685-2774) | In stock |
| [Nyx Professional Makeup Retractable Lip Liner](https://aislesinventory.com/new-york/products/nyx-professional-makeup-retractable-lip-liner-simon-macys-3324602-3711) | Cocoa | $6.00 | [Macy's Roosevelt Field, Garden City](https://aislesinventory.com/new-york/garden-city/macys-roosevelt-field-garden-city-roosevelt-field/nyx-professional-makeup-retractable-lip-liner-simon-macys-3324602-3711) | In stock |
| [Nyx Professional Makeup Slim Lip Pencil](https://aislesinventory.com/new-york/products/nyx-professional-makeup-nyx-professional-makeup-slim-lip-pencil-simon-jcpenney-ppr5008436587-2774) | 12 sizes/colors | $6.00 | [JCPenney Roosevelt Field, Garden City](https://aislesinventory.com/new-york/garden-city/jcpenney-roosevelt-field-garden-city-roosevelt-field/nyx-professional-makeup-nyx-professional-makeup-slim-lip-pencil-simon-jcpenney-ppr5008436587-2774) | In stock |
| [Real Techniques Miracle Complexion Sponge + Travel Case](https://aislesinventory.com/new-york/products/real-techniques-real-techniques-miracle-complexion-sponge-travel-case-simon-jcpenney-ppr5008701247-2774) | Size One Size | $6.00 | [JCPenney Roosevelt Field, Garden City](https://aislesinventory.com/new-york/garden-city/jcpenney-roosevelt-field-garden-city-roosevelt-field/real-techniques-real-techniques-miracle-complexion-sponge-travel-case-simon-jcpenney-ppr5008701247-2774) | In stock |
| [Eco Tools Blurring Blender](https://aislesinventory.com/new-york/products/eco-tools-eco-tools-blurring-blender-simon-jcpenney-ppr5008440514-2774) | Size One Size | $6.50 | [JCPenney Roosevelt Field, Garden City](https://aislesinventory.com/new-york/garden-city/jcpenney-roosevelt-field-garden-city-roosevelt-field/eco-tools-eco-tools-blurring-blender-simon-jcpenney-ppr5008440514-2774) | In stock |
| [St. Moriz Velvet Self Tanning Applicator Mitt](https://aislesinventory.com/new-york/products/st-moriz-st-moriz-velvet-self-tanning-applicator-mitt-simon-jcpenney-ppr5008155449-2774) | Size One Size, Velvet App Mitt | $6.99 | [JCPenney Roosevelt Field, Garden City](https://aislesinventory.com/new-york/garden-city/jcpenney-roosevelt-field-garden-city-roosevelt-field/st-moriz-st-moriz-velvet-self-tanning-applicator-mitt-simon-jcpenney-ppr5008155449-2774) | In stock |
| [Eco Tools Cream & Powder Dual-Ended Eye Brush](https://aislesinventory.com/new-york/products/eco-tools-eco-tools-cream-powder-dual-ended-eye-brush-simon-jcpenney-ppr5008690780-2774) | Size One Size | $7.00 | [JCPenney Roosevelt Field, Garden City](https://aislesinventory.com/new-york/garden-city/jcpenney-roosevelt-field-garden-city-roosevelt-field/eco-tools-eco-tools-cream-powder-dual-ended-eye-brush-simon-jcpenney-ppr5008690780-2774) | In stock |
| [Kimchi Chic Beauty Your Unicorn Mouth Lip Liner](https://aislesinventory.com/new-york/products/kimchi-kimchi-chic-beauty-your-unicorn-mouth-lip-liner-simon-jcpenney-ppr5008378419-2774) | 3 sizes/colors | $7.00 | [JCPenney Roosevelt Field, Garden City](https://aislesinventory.com/new-york/garden-city/jcpenney-roosevelt-field-garden-city-roosevelt-field/kimchi-kimchi-chic-beauty-your-unicorn-mouth-lip-liner-simon-jcpenney-ppr5008378419-2774) | In stock |
| [Real Techniques Miracle 2-In-1 Powder Puff](https://aislesinventory.com/new-york/products/real-techniques-real-techniques-miracle-2-in-1-powder-puff-simon-jcpenney-ppr5008441868-2774) | Size One Size | $7.00 | [JCPenney Roosevelt Field, Garden City](https://aislesinventory.com/new-york/garden-city/jcpenney-roosevelt-field-garden-city-roosevelt-field/real-techniques-real-techniques-miracle-2-in-1-powder-puff-simon-jcpenney-ppr5008441868-2774) | In stock |
| [Real Techniques Miracle Airblend Sponge](https://aislesinventory.com/new-york/products/real-techniques-real-techniques-miracle-airblend-sponge-simon-jcpenney-ppr5008188341-2774) | Size One Size | $7.00 | [JCPenney Roosevelt Field, Garden City](https://aislesinventory.com/new-york/garden-city/jcpenney-roosevelt-field-garden-city-roosevelt-field/real-techniques-real-techniques-miracle-airblend-sponge-simon-jcpenney-ppr5008188341-2774) | In stock |
| [Real Techniques Miracle Complexion Sponge](https://aislesinventory.com/new-york/products/real-techniques-real-techniques-miracle-complexion-sponge-simon-jcpenney-ppr5008187948-2774) | Size One Size | $7.00 | [JCPenney Roosevelt Field, Garden City](https://aislesinventory.com/new-york/garden-city/jcpenney-roosevelt-field-garden-city-roosevelt-field/real-techniques-real-techniques-miracle-complexion-sponge-simon-jcpenney-ppr5008187948-2774) | In stock |
| [Real Techniques Miracle Powder Sponge](https://aislesinventory.com/new-york/products/real-techniques-real-techniques-miracle-powder-sponge-simon-jcpenney-ppr5008187952-2774) | Size One Size | $7.00 | [JCPenney Roosevelt Field, Garden City](https://aislesinventory.com/new-york/garden-city/jcpenney-roosevelt-field-garden-city-roosevelt-field/real-techniques-real-techniques-miracle-powder-sponge-simon-jcpenney-ppr5008187952-2774) | In stock |
| [Kimchi Chic Beauty Spinning Hearts Duo](https://aislesinventory.com/new-york/products/kimchi-kimchi-chic-beauty-spinning-hearts-duo-simon-jcpenney-ppr5008378427-2774) | 3 sizes/colors | $8.00 | [JCPenney Roosevelt Field, Garden City](https://aislesinventory.com/new-york/garden-city/jcpenney-roosevelt-field-garden-city-roosevelt-field/kimchi-kimchi-chic-beauty-spinning-hearts-duo-simon-jcpenney-ppr5008378427-2774) | In stock |
| [Nyx Professional Makeup Vivid Rich Retractable Eyeliner](https://aislesinventory.com/new-york/products/nyx-professional-makeup-nyx-professional-makeup-vivid-rich-simon-macys-17255662-3711) | Size 0.09 oz, Tigers Prize | $8.00 | [Macy's Roosevelt Field, Garden City](https://aislesinventory.com/new-york/garden-city/macys-roosevelt-field-garden-city-roosevelt-field/nyx-professional-makeup-nyx-professional-makeup-vivid-rich-simon-macys-17255662-3711) | In stock |
| [Real Techniques Liner & Smudge Brush](https://aislesinventory.com/new-york/products/real-techniques-real-techniques-liner-smudge-brush-simon-jcpenney-ppr5008660168-2774) | Size One Size | $8.00 | [JCPenney Roosevelt Field, Garden City](https://aislesinventory.com/new-york/garden-city/jcpenney-roosevelt-field-garden-city-roosevelt-field/real-techniques-real-techniques-liner-smudge-brush-simon-jcpenney-ppr5008660168-2774) | In stock |
| [Covergirl Perfect Point Plus Eyeliner](https://aislesinventory.com/new-york/products/covergirl-covergirl-perfect-point-plus-eyeliner-simon-jcpenney-ppr5008160126-2774) | 2 sizes/colors | $8.49 | [JCPenney Roosevelt Field, Garden City](https://aislesinventory.com/new-york/garden-city/jcpenney-roosevelt-field-garden-city-roosevelt-field/covergirl-covergirl-perfect-point-plus-eyeliner-simon-jcpenney-ppr5008160126-2774) | In stock |

[All 1,881 products in Makeup](https://aislesinventory.com/new-york/categories/makeup)

## Cheapest by chain

| Chain | Cheapest in-stock item | Price | Where |
| --- | --- | --- | --- |
| ATHLETA | Athleta Women's Foundation Cap Sleeve Tee (5 sizes/colors) | $31.50 | [ATHLETA Roosevelt Field, Garden City](https://aislesinventory.com/new-york/garden-city/athleta-roosevelt-field-garden-city-roosevelt-field/athleta-womens-foundation-cap-sleeve-tee-simon-athleta-1174500-22419) |
| Dick's Sporting Goods | Gk Elite Chasse Barbie Glitter Cheer Hair Bow, Men's, Pink (Size One Size, Pink) | $10.99 | [Dick's Sporting Goods Roosevelt Field, Garden City](https://aislesinventory.com/new-york/garden-city/dicks-sporting-goods-roosevelt-field-garden-city-roosevelt-field/gk-elite-chasse-barbie-glitter-cheer-hair-bow-mens-pink-simon-dicks-sporting-goods-26gkeucheeg8y1k1vdbzm-1574) |
| Express | Express Body Contour Light Compression Cap Sleeve Tee in Stretch Cotton (12 sizes/colors) | $23.80 | [Express Roosevelt Field, Garden City](https://aislesinventory.com/new-york/garden-city/express-roosevelt-field-garden-city-roosevelt-field/express-body-contour-light-compression-cap-sleeve-tee-in-stretch-simon-express-06413909-1846) |
| JCPenney | Ardell Wispies, Demi, 1 Pair (Size One Size, Black) | $4.50 | [JCPenney Roosevelt Field, Garden City](https://aislesinventory.com/new-york/garden-city/jcpenney-roosevelt-field-garden-city-roosevelt-field/ardell-ardell-wispies-demi-1-pair-simon-jcpenney-ppr5008202654-2774) |
| Macy's | Nyx Professional Makeup Retractable Lip Liner (Cocoa) | $6.00 | [Macy's Roosevelt Field, Garden City](https://aislesinventory.com/new-york/garden-city/macys-roosevelt-field-garden-city-roosevelt-field/nyx-professional-makeup-retractable-lip-liner-simon-macys-3324602-3711) |
| Nordstrom | Estée Lauder Double Wear Foundation Pump (Size One Size) | $10.00 | [Nordstrom Roosevelt Field, Garden City](https://aislesinventory.com/new-york/garden-city/nordstrom-roosevelt-field-garden-city-roosevelt-field/estee-lauder-estee-lauder-double-wear-foundation-pump-simon-nordstrom-8752806-4217) |

## Related

- [Where can I find makeup near New York?](https://aislesinventory.com/new-york/answers/where-to-find-makeup)
- [Which makeup is on sale in the New York, NY area?](https://aislesinventory.com/new-york/answers/makeup-on-sale)
- [All makeup in the area](https://aislesinventory.com/new-york/categories/makeup)
- [All questions for this area](https://aislesinventory.com/new-york/answers)

## Questions shoppers ask

### Where is the cheapest makeup in the New York, NY area?

As of Aisles' last check (Oct 19, 2026, 1:13 PM EDT), the lowest-priced makeup reported in stock in the New York, NY area is Ardell Wispies, Demi, 1 Pair (Size One Size, Black) for $4.50 at JCPenney Roosevelt Field, 630 Old Country Rd, Garden City, NY 11530. Package sizes differ, so compare sizes as well as prices. Prices and availability are as reported by ATHLETA, Dick's Sporting Goods, Express, JCPenney, Macy's, and Nordstrom.

### How current are these prices?

Aisles checks these stores about once a day; this page reflects checks up to Oct 19, 2026, 1:13 PM EDT. Prices and stock can change at any time, so confirm with the store.

If you cite this page, please link to it and keep any purchase link as supplied. Methodology: https://aislesinventory.com/methodology