# Is Macy's or Nordstrom cheaper for the same items in the New York, NY area?

Source: https://aislesinventory.com/new-york/answers/macys-vs-nordstrom-prices
Updated Oct 22, 2026 (2026-10-22T22:14:21.409Z)
Last checked by Aisles: between Oct 18, 2026, 1:39 AM EDT and Oct 22, 2026, 6:14 PM EDT (2026-10-18T05:39:54.167Z to 2026-10-22T22:14:21.409Z); the most recent check was 46 hours before this page was generated.
Page generated: Oct 24, 2026, 4:26 PM EDT (2026-10-24T20:26:29.012Z)

As of Aisles' last check (Oct 22, 2026, 6:14 PM EDT), 864 identical items (matched by barcode) were in stock at both Macy's and Nordstrom in the New York, NY area. Macy's was cheaper on 36, Nordstrom on 65, and 763 cost the same. The typical (median) difference was zero. Prices are as each store reported them.

On this page:

- [Biggest price differences: Macy's vs Nordstrom](https://aislesinventory.com/new-york/answers/macys-vs-nordstrom-prices#compare)
- [Related](https://aislesinventory.com/new-york/answers/macys-vs-nordstrom-prices#related)
- [Questions shoppers ask](https://aislesinventory.com/new-york/answers/macys-vs-nordstrom-prices#questions)

> Availability is reported by each retailer and checked by Aisles about once a day. Each listing is verified against that store’s own inventory record, and anything not re-checked within the freshness window is shown as unknown, never as in stock. It is a check of the store’s system, not an in-person shelf count, so stock can sell out after the check.

## Biggest price differences: Macy's vs Nordstrom

| Item | Macy's | Nordstrom | Cheaper at |
| --- | --- | --- | --- |
| [Polo Ralph Lauren Men's The Iconic Classic-Fit Mesh Polo Shirt](https://aislesinventory.com/new-york/products/polo-ralph-lauren-mens-the-iconic-classic-fit-mesh-polo-shirt-simon-macys-23785240-3711) | $40.33 | $88.50 | Macy's |
| [Polo Ralph Lauren Men's The Iconic Classic-Fit Mesh Polo Shirt](https://aislesinventory.com/new-york/products/polo-ralph-lauren-mens-the-iconic-classic-fit-mesh-polo-shirt-simon-macys-23785240-3711) | $40.33 | $88.50 | Macy's |
| [Polo Ralph Lauren Baby Girls' Crewneck T-Shirt and Terry Shorts, 2-Piece Set](https://aislesinventory.com/new-york/products/polo-ralph-lauren-baby-girls-crewneck-t-shirt-and-terry-shorts-2-simon-macys-25107633-3711) | $29.93 | $75.00 | Macy's |
| [Nike Women's Sportswear Phoenix Fleece Oversized Pullover Hoodie](https://aislesinventory.com/new-york/products/nike-nike-womens-sportswear-phoenix-fleece-oversized-pullover-hoodie-simon-macys-19912380-3711) | $31.93 | $75.00 | Macy's |
| [Nike Women's Sportswear Phoenix Fleece Oversized Pullover Hoodie](https://aislesinventory.com/new-york/products/nike-nike-womens-sportswear-phoenix-fleece-oversized-pullover-hoodie-simon-macys-19912380-3711) | $31.93 | $75.00 | Macy's |
| [Nike Sportswear Women's Phoenix Fleece High-Rise Oversized Sweatpants](https://aislesinventory.com/new-york/products/nike-nike-sportswear-womens-phoenix-fleece-high-rise-oversized-simon-macys-20432094-3711) | $29.93 | $70.00 | Macy's |
| [Sam Edelman Women's Tabbey Slip-On Sandals](https://aislesinventory.com/new-york/products/sam-edelman-sam-edelman-womens-tabbey-slip-on-sandals-simon-macys-25559596-3711) | $91.00 | $58.49 | Nordstrom |
| [Sam Edelman Women's Tabbey Slip-On Sandals](https://aislesinventory.com/new-york/products/sam-edelman-sam-edelman-womens-tabbey-slip-on-sandals-simon-macys-25559596-3711) | $91.00 | $58.49 | Nordstrom |
| [Sam Edelman Women's Tabbey Slip-On Sandals](https://aislesinventory.com/new-york/products/sam-edelman-sam-edelman-womens-tabbey-slip-on-sandals-simon-macys-25559596-3711) | $91.00 | $58.49 | Nordstrom |
| [Sam Edelman Women's Tabbey Slip-On Sandals](https://aislesinventory.com/new-york/products/sam-edelman-sam-edelman-womens-tabbey-slip-on-sandals-simon-macys-25559596-3711) | $91.00 | $58.49 | Nordstrom |
| [Wacoal Women's Back Appeal Wirefree Contour Bra 856303](https://aislesinventory.com/new-york/products/wacoal-wacoal-womens-back-appeal-wirefree-contour-bra-856303-simon-macys-13638677-3711) | $76.00 | $45.60 | Nordstrom |
| [Wacoal Women's Back Appeal Underwire Bra 855303](https://aislesinventory.com/new-york/products/wacoal-wacoal-womens-back-appeal-underwire-bra-855303-simon-macys-27606437-3711) | $44.40 | $74.00 | Macy's |
| [Wacoal Women's Back Appeal Underwire Bra 855303](https://aislesinventory.com/new-york/products/wacoal-wacoal-womens-back-appeal-underwire-bra-855303-simon-macys-27606437-3711) | $44.40 | $74.00 | Macy's |
| [Polo Ralph Lauren Men's Classic-Fit Mesh Polo Shirt](https://aislesinventory.com/new-york/products/polo-ralph-lauren-polo-ralph-lauren-mens-classic-fit-mesh-polo-shirt-simon-macys-14380976-3711) | $118.00 | $88.50 | Nordstrom |
| [Polo Ralph Lauren Men's Classic-Fit Mesh Polo Shirt](https://aislesinventory.com/new-york/products/polo-ralph-lauren-polo-ralph-lauren-mens-classic-fit-mesh-polo-shirt-simon-macys-14380976-3711) | $118.00 | $88.50 | Nordstrom |
| [Polo Ralph Lauren Men's Classic-Fit Mesh Polo Shirt](https://aislesinventory.com/new-york/products/polo-ralph-lauren-polo-ralph-lauren-mens-classic-fit-mesh-polo-shirt-simon-macys-14380976-3711) | $118.00 | $88.50 | Nordstrom |
| [Polo Ralph Lauren Men's Classic-Fit Mesh Polo Shirt](https://aislesinventory.com/new-york/products/polo-ralph-lauren-polo-ralph-lauren-mens-classic-fit-mesh-polo-shirt-simon-macys-14380976-3711) | $118.00 | $88.50 | Nordstrom |
| [Polo Ralph Lauren Men's Classic-Fit Mesh Polo Shirt](https://aislesinventory.com/new-york/products/polo-ralph-lauren-polo-ralph-lauren-mens-classic-fit-mesh-polo-shirt-simon-macys-14380976-3711) | $118.00 | $88.50 | Nordstrom |
| [Kate Spade New York Golden Bloom Cubic Zirconia Flower Pendant Necklace](https://aislesinventory.com/new-york/products/kate-spade-new-york-golden-bloom-cubic-zirconia-flower-pendant-simon-macys-25718500-3711) | $34.80 | $58.00 | Macy's |
| [Kiehl's Since 1851 Creme de Corps Body Lotion with Cocoa Butter, 16.9 oz.](https://aislesinventory.com/new-york/products/kiehls-since-1851-creme-de-corps-body-lotion-with-cocoa-butter-16-9-oz-simon-macys-3847673-3711) | $60.00 | $42.00 | Nordstrom |
| [The North Face Boy's and Girl's Youth Court Jester Backpack](https://aislesinventory.com/new-york/products/the-north-face-the-north-face-boys-and-girls-youth-court-jester-simon-macys-28438774-3711) | $45.00 | $60.00 | Macy's |
| [The North Face Youth Court Jester Backpack](https://aislesinventory.com/new-york/products/the-north-face-youth-court-jester-backpack-simon-macys-13264509-3711) | $45.00 | $60.00 | Macy's |
| [Kiehl's Since 1851 Facial Fuel Invigorating Face Wash, 16.9 oz.](https://aislesinventory.com/new-york/products/kiehls-since-1851-facial-fuel-invigorating-face-wash-16-9-oz-simon-macys-3847591-3711) | $45.00 | $31.50 | Nordstrom |
| [Kiehl's Since 1851 Amino Acid Shampoo, 16.9-oz.](https://aislesinventory.com/new-york/products/kiehls-since-1851-amino-acid-shampoo-16-9-oz-simon-macys-3847677-3711) | $42.00 | $29.40 | Nordstrom |
| [Kiehl's Since 1851 Ultra Facial Cream With Squalane, 1.7 oz.](https://aislesinventory.com/new-york/products/kiehls-since-1851-ultra-facial-cream-with-squalane-1-7-oz-simon-macys-4895490-3711) | $39.00 | $27.30 | Nordstrom |
| [Kiehl's Since 1851 Creme de Corps Body Lotion with Cocoa Butter, 8.4 oz.](https://aislesinventory.com/new-york/products/kiehls-since-1851-creme-de-corps-body-lotion-with-cocoa-butter-8-4-oz-simon-macys-3847665-3711) | $39.00 | $27.30 | Nordstrom |
| [Natori Women's Bliss Bare Cotton Hipster Underwear 774346](https://aislesinventory.com/new-york/products/natori-natori-womens-bliss-bare-cotton-hipster-underwear-774346-simon-macys-20898809-3711) | $13.20 | $22.00 | Macy's |
| [Kiehl's Since 1851 Facial Fuel Energizing Face Wash, 8.4 oz.](https://aislesinventory.com/new-york/products/kiehls-since-1851-facial-fuel-energizing-face-wash-8-4-oz-simon-macys-4937889-3711) | $28.00 | $19.60 | Nordstrom |
| [Kiehl's Since 1851 Body Fuel All-In-One Energizing Wash, 33.8 fl. oz.](https://aislesinventory.com/new-york/products/kiehls-since-1851-body-fuel-all-in-one-energizing-wash-33-8-fl-oz-simon-macys-2479080-3711) | $68.00 | $60.00 | Nordstrom |
| [Kiehl's Since 1851 Ultra Facial Cream with Squalane, 0.95 oz.](https://aislesinventory.com/new-york/products/kiehls-since-1851-ultra-facial-cream-with-squalane-0-95-oz-simon-macys-8024604-3711) | $26.00 | $18.20 | Nordstrom |
| [Kiehl's Since 1851 Ultimate Strength Hand Salve, 2.5-oz.](https://aislesinventory.com/new-york/products/kiehls-since-1851-kiehls-since-1851-ultimate-strength-hand-salve-2-5-simon-macys-3847676-3711) | $22.00 | $15.40 | Nordstrom |
| [Polo Ralph Lauren Boys 4-11 3-Pack Super Soft Crew Socks](https://aislesinventory.com/new-york/products/polo-ralph-lauren-polo-ralph-lauren-boys-4-11-3-pack-super-soft-crew-simon-macys-4331683-3711) | $15.00 | $20.00 | Macy's |
| [Polo Ralph Lauren Boys 4-11 3-Pack Super Soft Crew Socks](https://aislesinventory.com/new-york/products/polo-ralph-lauren-polo-ralph-lauren-boys-4-11-3-pack-super-soft-crew-simon-macys-4331683-3711) | $15.00 | $20.00 | Macy's |
| [Ecco Men's Metropole Milan Plain Toe Derby Shoe](https://aislesinventory.com/new-york/products/ecco-mens-metropole-milan-plain-toe-derby-shoe-simon-macys-20749306-3711) | $185.00 | $190.00 | Macy's |
| [Ecco Men's Metropole Milan Plain Toe Derby Shoe](https://aislesinventory.com/new-york/products/ecco-mens-metropole-milan-plain-toe-derby-shoe-simon-macys-20749306-3711) | $185.00 | $190.00 | Macy's |
| [Ecco Men's Metropole Milan Plain Toe Derby Shoe](https://aislesinventory.com/new-york/products/ecco-mens-metropole-milan-plain-toe-derby-shoe-simon-macys-20749306-3711) | $185.00 | $190.00 | Macy's |
| [Ecco Men's Metropole Milan Plain Toe Derby Shoe](https://aislesinventory.com/new-york/products/ecco-mens-metropole-milan-plain-toe-derby-shoe-simon-macys-20749306-3711) | $185.00 | $190.00 | Macy's |
| [Ecco Men's Metropole Milan Plain Toe Derby Shoe](https://aislesinventory.com/new-york/products/ecco-mens-metropole-milan-plain-toe-derby-shoe-simon-macys-20749306-3711) | $185.00 | $190.00 | Macy's |
| [Ecco Men's Metropole Milan Plain Toe Derby Shoe](https://aislesinventory.com/new-york/products/ecco-mens-metropole-milan-plain-toe-derby-shoe-simon-macys-20749306-3711) | $185.00 | $190.00 | Macy's |
| [Ecco Men's Metropole Milan Plain Toe Derby Shoe](https://aislesinventory.com/new-york/products/ecco-mens-metropole-milan-plain-toe-derby-shoe-simon-macys-20749306-3711) | $185.00 | $190.00 | Macy's |
| [Ecco Men's Metropole Milan Plain Toe Derby Shoe](https://aislesinventory.com/new-york/products/ecco-mens-metropole-milan-plain-toe-derby-shoe-simon-macys-20749306-3711) | $185.00 | $190.00 | Macy's |
| [Nike Women's Sportswear Phoenix Fleece Oversized Pullover Hoodie](https://aislesinventory.com/new-york/products/nike-nike-womens-sportswear-phoenix-fleece-oversized-pullover-hoodie-simon-macys-19912380-3711) | $80.00 | $75.00 | Nordstrom |
| [Nike Women's Sportswear Phoenix Fleece Oversized Pullover Hoodie](https://aislesinventory.com/new-york/products/nike-nike-womens-sportswear-phoenix-fleece-oversized-pullover-hoodie-simon-macys-19912380-3711) | $80.00 | $75.00 | Nordstrom |
| [Nike Women's Sportswear Phoenix Fleece Oversized Pullover Hoodie](https://aislesinventory.com/new-york/products/nike-nike-womens-sportswear-phoenix-fleece-oversized-pullover-hoodie-simon-macys-19912380-3711) | $80.00 | $75.00 | Nordstrom |
| [Nike Women's Sportswear Phoenix Fleece Oversized Pullover Hoodie](https://aislesinventory.com/new-york/products/nike-nike-womens-sportswear-phoenix-fleece-oversized-pullover-hoodie-simon-macys-19912380-3711) | $80.00 | $75.00 | Nordstrom |
| [Nike Women's Sportswear Phoenix Fleece Oversized Pullover Hoodie](https://aislesinventory.com/new-york/products/nike-nike-womens-sportswear-phoenix-fleece-oversized-pullover-hoodie-simon-macys-19912380-3711) | $80.00 | $75.00 | Nordstrom |
| [Nike Sportswear Women's Phoenix Fleece High-Rise Oversized Sweatpants](https://aislesinventory.com/new-york/products/nike-nike-sportswear-womens-phoenix-fleece-high-rise-oversized-simon-macys-20432094-3711) | $75.00 | $70.00 | Nordstrom |
| [Nike Sportswear Women's Phoenix Fleece High-Rise Oversized Sweatpants](https://aislesinventory.com/new-york/products/nike-nike-sportswear-womens-phoenix-fleece-high-rise-oversized-simon-macys-20432094-3711) | $75.00 | $70.00 | Nordstrom |
| [Nike Sportswear Women's Phoenix Fleece High-Rise Oversized Sweatpants](https://aislesinventory.com/new-york/products/nike-nike-sportswear-womens-phoenix-fleece-high-rise-oversized-simon-macys-20432094-3711) | $75.00 | $70.00 | Nordstrom |
| [Nike Sportswear Women's Phoenix Fleece High-Rise Oversized Sweatpants](https://aislesinventory.com/new-york/products/nike-nike-sportswear-womens-phoenix-fleece-high-rise-oversized-simon-macys-20432094-3711) | $75.00 | $70.00 | Nordstrom |

## Related

- [Is JCPenney or Macy's cheaper for the same items in the New York, NY area?](https://aislesinventory.com/new-york/answers/jcpenney-vs-macys-prices)
- [Is Dick's Sporting Goods or Foot Locker cheaper for the same items in the New York, NY area?](https://aislesinventory.com/new-york/answers/dicks-sporting-goods-vs-foot-locker-prices)
- [Is Dick's Sporting Goods or Macy's cheaper for the same items in the New York, NY area?](https://aislesinventory.com/new-york/answers/dicks-sporting-goods-vs-macys-prices)
- [Is Dick's Sporting Goods or JCPenney cheaper for the same items in the New York, NY area?](https://aislesinventory.com/new-york/answers/dicks-sporting-goods-vs-jcpenney-prices)
- [Is Foot Locker or Macy's cheaper for the same items in the New York, NY area?](https://aislesinventory.com/new-york/answers/foot-locker-vs-macys-prices)
- [Is Dick's Sporting Goods or Nordstrom cheaper for the same items in the New York, NY area?](https://aislesinventory.com/new-york/answers/dicks-sporting-goods-vs-nordstrom-prices)
- [Is Levi's® or Macy's cheaper for the same items in the New York, NY area?](https://aislesinventory.com/new-york/answers/levis-vs-macys-prices)
- [Is Aerie or OFFLINE by Aerie cheaper for the same items in the New York, NY area?](https://aislesinventory.com/new-york/answers/aerie-vs-offline-by-aerie-prices)
- [Is JCPenney or Levi's® cheaper for the same items in the New York, NY area?](https://aislesinventory.com/new-york/answers/jcpenney-vs-levis-prices)
- [Is Foot Locker or Nordstrom cheaper for the same items in the New York, NY area?](https://aislesinventory.com/new-york/answers/foot-locker-vs-nordstrom-prices)
- [Is Foot Locker or JCPenney cheaper for the same items in the New York, NY area?](https://aislesinventory.com/new-york/answers/foot-locker-vs-jcpenney-prices)
- [Is JCPenney or Nordstrom cheaper for the same items in the New York, NY area?](https://aislesinventory.com/new-york/answers/jcpenney-vs-nordstrom-prices)
- [Is Macy's or Pacsun cheaper for the same items in the New York, NY area?](https://aislesinventory.com/new-york/answers/macys-vs-pacsun-prices)
- [All questions for this area](https://aislesinventory.com/new-york/answers)

## Questions shoppers ask

### Is Macy's or Nordstrom cheaper for the same items in the New York, NY area?

As of Aisles' last check (Oct 22, 2026, 6:14 PM EDT), 864 identical items (matched by barcode) were in stock at both Macy's and Nordstrom in the New York, NY area. Macy's was cheaper on 36, Nordstrom on 65, and 763 cost the same. The typical (median) difference was zero. Prices are as each store reported them.

### How are items matched?

Only items with the same barcode (GTIN/UPC) at both stores are compared, using the lowest in-stock price each store reported.

If you cite this page, please link to it and keep any purchase link as supplied. Methodology: https://aislesinventory.com/methodology