Where are the cheapest women's shoes in the New York, NY area?
As of Aisles' last check (Oct 24, 2026, 12:18 PM EDT), the lowest-priced women's shoes reported in stock in the New York, NY area is Mixit Womens Flip-Flops (12 sizes/colors) for $6.00 at JCPenney Roosevelt Field, 630 Old Country Rd, Garden City, NY 11530. Package sizes differ, so compare sizes as well as prices. Prices and availability are as reported by Aerie, American Eagle, Dick's Sporting Goods, Foot Locker, Gap, JCPenney, JD, Macy's, Michael Kors, Nordstrom, OFFLINE by Aerie, and The Children's Place.
Last checked by Aisles: between and (13 hours before this page was generated)
About this data (1 note)
Availability is reported by each retailer and checked by Aisles about once a day. Each listing is verified against that store’s own inventory record, and anything not re-checked within the freshness window is shown as unknown, never as in stock. It is a check of the store’s system, not an in-person shelf count, so stock can sell out after the check.
Lowest in-stock price for each women's shoes product
| Product | Size | Lowest price | Where | Availability |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Mixit Womens Flip-Flops | 12 sizes/colors | $6.00 | JCPenney Roosevelt Field, Garden City | In stock |
| Mixit Womens Glitter Zori Flip-Flops | 10 sizes/colors | $6.00 | JCPenney Roosevelt Field, Garden City | In stock |
| The Children's Place Girls Paint Splatter Buckle Slides | Size YOUTH 11, White | $7.48 | The Children's Place Roosevelt Field, Garden City | In stock |
| Mixit Womens Flip-Flops | 7 sizes/colors | $8.00 | JCPenney Roosevelt Field, Garden City | In stock |
| Rochester Premium All Purpose Shoe & Boot Protector in N/a | Size One Size | $8.00 | Nordstrom Roosevelt Field, Garden City | In stock |
| Rochester Shoe & Boot Cleaner in N/a | Size One Size | $8.00 | Nordstrom Roosevelt Field, Garden City | In stock |
| The Children's Place Adult Matching Family Santa Slippers | 2 sizes/colors | $8.98 | The Children's Place Roosevelt Field, Garden City | In stock |
| The Children's Place Girls Glitter Jelly Buckle Slides | 3 sizes/colors | $8.98 | The Children's Place Roosevelt Field, Garden City | In stock |
Show all 25 rows
Cheapest by chain
| Chain | Cheapest in-stock item | Price | Where |
|---|---|---|---|
| Aerie | Aerie Kitsch Slick Stick (Size One Size, Terracotta) | $13.95 | Aerie Roosevelt Field, Garden City |
| American Eagle | American Eagle AE Crochet Flower Sandal (6 sizes/colors) | $15.98 | American Eagle Roosevelt Field, Garden City |
| Dick's Sporting Goods | Lock Laces No-Tie Boot Laces, Camo (3 sizes/colors) | $11.99 | Dick's Sporting Goods Roosevelt Field, Garden City |
| Foot Locker | Havaianas Womens Top Sandals (3 sizes/colors) | $24.00 | Foot Locker Roosevelt Field, Garden City |
| Gap | Gap Women's Vegan Suede Ballet Flats (6 sizes/colors) | $29.00 | Gap Roosevelt Field, Garden City |
| JCPenney | Mixit Womens Flip-Flops (12 sizes/colors) | $6.00 | JCPenney Roosevelt Field, Garden City |
| JD | Nike Women's ReactX Rejuven8 Slide Sandals (9 sizes/colors) | $30.00 | JD Roosevelt Field, Garden City |
| Macy's | State Of Day Women's Open Toe Boxed Slippers, Macy's Exclusive (4 sizes/colors) | $15.73 | Macy's Roosevelt Field, Garden City |
| Michael Kors | Michael Kors Fulton Suede Moccasin (6 sizes/colors) | $69.00 | Michael Kors Roosevelt Field, Garden City |
| Nordstrom | Rochester Premium All Purpose Shoe & Boot Protector in N/a (Size One Size) | $8.00 | Nordstrom Roosevelt Field, Garden City |
| OFFLINE by Aerie | Aerie Nylon Crescent Bag (Size One Size, Natural) | $34.95 | OFFLINE by Aerie Roosevelt Field, Garden City |
| The Children's Place | The Children's Place Girls Paint Splatter Buckle Slides (Size YOUTH 11, White) | $7.48 | The Children's Place Roosevelt Field, Garden City |
Questions shoppers ask
Where are the cheapest women's shoes in the New York, NY area?
As of Aisles' last check (Oct 24, 2026, 12:18 PM EDT), the lowest-priced women's shoes reported in stock in the New York, NY area is Mixit Womens Flip-Flops (12 sizes/colors) for $6.00 at JCPenney Roosevelt Field, 630 Old Country Rd, Garden City, NY 11530. Package sizes differ, so compare sizes as well as prices. Prices and availability are as reported by Aerie, American Eagle, Dick's Sporting Goods, Foot Locker, Gap, JCPenney, JD, Macy's, Michael Kors, Nordstrom, OFFLINE by Aerie, and The Children's Place.
How current are these prices?
Aisles checks these stores about once a day; this page reflects checks up to Oct 24, 2026, 12:18 PM EDT. Stock can sell out after the check time shown.
Page generated . Availability is as reported by each retailer at the time Aisles last checked.