Is JCPenney or Macy's cheaper for the same items in the New York, NY area?
As of Aisles' last check (Oct 20, 2026, 5:18 PM EDT), 6,480 identical items (matched by barcode) were in stock at both JCPenney and Macy's in the New York, NY area. JCPenney was cheaper on 3990, Macy's on 652, and 1838 cost the same. The typical (median) difference was $6.25 in favor of JCPenney. Prices are as each store reported them.
Last checked by Aisles: between and (29 hours before this page was generated)
About this data (1 note)
Availability is reported by each retailer and checked by Aisles about once a day. It can change at any time, and Aisles does not physically verify stock. Confirm with the store before making a special trip.
Biggest price differences: JCPenney vs Macy's
| Item | JCPenney | Macy's | Cheaper at |
|---|---|---|---|
| Bobby Flay Ceramic Non-Stick 13-pc. Cookware Set | $249.99 | $416.99 | JCPenney |
| Bulova Marine Star Mens Automatic Gold Tone Stainless Steel Bracelet Watch 98a273 | $675.75 | $795.00 | JCPenney |
| Bulova Marine Star Mens Automatic Black Strap Watch 98a272 | $637.50 | $750.00 | JCPenney |
| Bulova Classic Sutton Womens Automatic Gold Tone Stainless Steel Bracelet Watch 97l172 | $590.75 | $695.00 | JCPenney |
| Bulova Classic Mens Chronograph Black Stainless Steel Bracelet Watch 98d133 | $488.75 | $575.00 | JCPenney |
| Citizen Bianca Womens Diamond Accent Two Tone Stainless Steel Bracelet Watch Ew5554-58d | $467.50 | $550.00 | JCPenney |
| Bulova Futuro Mens Diamond Accent Gold Tone Stainless Steel Bracelet Watch 97d116 | $467.50 | $550.00 | JCPenney |
| Bulova Classic Womens Diamond Accent Two Tone Stainless Steel Bracelet Watch 98p202 | $467.50 | $550.00 | JCPenney |
Show all 50 rows
Questions shoppers ask
Is JCPenney or Macy's cheaper for the same items in the New York, NY area?
As of Aisles' last check (Oct 20, 2026, 5:18 PM EDT), 6,480 identical items (matched by barcode) were in stock at both JCPenney and Macy's in the New York, NY area. JCPenney was cheaper on 3990, Macy's on 652, and 1838 cost the same. The typical (median) difference was $6.25 in favor of JCPenney. Prices are as each store reported them.
How are items matched?
Only items with the same barcode (GTIN/UPC) at both stores are compared, using the lowest in-stock price each store reported.
Page generated . Availability is as reported by each retailer at the time Aisles last checked.